Why I Stopped Buying Stocks and Started Selling Puts Instead
Most investors buy stocks and hope they go up. I flipped the model — now I collect premium income whether the market rises, stays flat, or drops a little. Here's exactly how I think about it.
Most investors have the same mental model: buy a stock, wait for it to go up, sell it for a profit.
I did that for years. It worked when the market went up. It didn't work when it didn't. Selling puts instead changes the game: you profit in three out of four market scenarios instead of one, and time decay puts money in your pocket every day just from time passing.
Then I started selling puts instead. Here's what changed.
What's the Problem With Just Buying Stocks?
When you buy a stock, you're making a directional bet. The stock has to go up for you to make money. If it goes sideways for a year, you earn nothing. If it drops, you lose.
You're completely at the mercy of price movement.
The other problem: time is neutral. A stock sitting flat costs you nothing but gives you nothing either. You're waiting.
What Changes When You Sell Options
When you sell a put option, you're not betting that a stock goes up. You're betting that it doesn't crash below a specific level by a specific date.
That's a very different bet.
SPY can go up, stay flat, or even drop a few percent — and you still keep the premium you collected at the start. You win in three out of four market scenarios instead of one.
And here's the part most people miss: time works in your favor. Every day that passes, the option you sold loses value (theta decay). You're not waiting for something to happen — the passage of time itself generates your return.
Why Bull Put Spreads Specifically
Selling naked puts carries unlimited risk if something goes catastrophically wrong. A Bull Put Spread solves that.
You sell a put at one strike, and buy a cheaper put at a lower strike. The spread between them caps your maximum loss. You still collect premium, still benefit from theta decay — but your worst-case scenario is defined and finite.
This is why serious options income traders gravitate toward Bull Put Spreads: it's premium selling with a built-in circuit breaker.
Why Does Systematic Execution Matter for Options Income?
The reason most traders fail at options isn't the strategy — it's inconsistency.
They sell puts when they feel confident. They panic and close too early when the market dips. They skip weeks when things feel uncertain. They over-concentrate in one stock when it feels "obvious."
The traders who build consistent options income treat it like a system:
- Entry rules: only when IV Rank is elevated (options are expensive)
- Strike selection: based on delta, not gut feel
- Position sizing: fixed contracts per symbol, regardless of conviction
- Exit rules: close at 50% profit target, defend at specific breach levels
The system removes the emotion. The emotion is what kills returns.
What I Track Now
Once you're running multiple positions across different symbols and expiration dates, tracking becomes non-trivial. You need to know:
- What's your current Delta exposure across the whole portfolio?
- Which positions are approaching their alert thresholds?
- What's the IV Rank on each underlying right now?
- Which positions need to be rolled or closed?
A spreadsheet works for 3 positions. It breaks down at 10.
That's the gap BPS Tracker was built to fill — a purpose-built tool for Bull Put Spread traders who want to run a systematic options income strategy without drowning in spreadsheets.
Is This Risk-Free?
No. Nothing in markets is risk-free.
Bull Put Spreads can lose. A sharp, fast market drop that blows through your spread width will result in a loss. The goal of a systematic approach isn't to eliminate losses — it's to ensure that your wins, over time, are larger and more frequent than your losses.
The edge comes from selling elevated implied volatility, collecting premium that statistically over-prices actual realized moves, and managing positions consistently.
It's not exciting. It's not going to make you rich overnight. But for traders who want a repeatable, systematic way to generate options income — it's one of the most straightforward paths available.
Speaking of "selling elevated implied volatility" — how do you know when IV is actually elevated? What's the benchmark?
That's where VIX comes in: the market's overall volatility gauge, and the first thing options sellers should check before opening any position.
What Is VIX? The Fear Index Every Options Trader Should Know →
Frequently Asked Questions
- Why sell puts instead of buying stocks?
- When you buy a stock, you profit only when it rises — one scenario out of four. When you sell a put, you profit in three scenarios: stock rises, stays flat, or drops a little. Additionally, Theta decay generates returns every day just from time passing, regardless of price movement.
- What is the advantage of Bull Put Spreads over naked puts?
- Naked puts carry theoretically unlimited risk if a stock crashes. A Bull Put Spread adds a lower-strike long put that caps your maximum loss at the spread width minus the net credit — for example, $400 per contract on a $5-wide spread collecting $1.00.
- What rules make a systematic options income strategy work?
- The key four rules: enter only when IV Rank is elevated, select strikes by delta (not gut feel), use fixed position sizing regardless of conviction level, and exit at 50% profit target. The system removes emotion — and emotion is what kills options returns.
- How many BPS positions can I track with a spreadsheet?
- A spreadsheet works for about 3 positions. At 10 positions across different symbols and expiration dates, manually tracking Delta exposure, IV Rank, and alert thresholds becomes error-prone. Purpose-built tools like BPS Tracker automate this tracking.
Ready to track your BPS positions?
BPS Tracker gives you real-time Greeks, IV Rank, and AI analysis — trade with data.
Download on App Store — Free